How do I make my agency stand out when competitors sell the same services?
A plain AI gives a homepage template. With a positioning pack, the same AI writes the lines rivals don't already own, and drops the ones they do.
Stop listing your services, because your rivals list the same ones, and say the one thing none of them can. For Chairside Growth, the fictional dental agency in our sample, that means a homepage built on the gap its rivals leave open: "Fill the implant and Invisalign slots already in your diary", with every channel pointed at the treatment a practice has free and reception left as it is. It also means dropping "booked patients over clicks", because a rival's homepage already says it.
This page is a worked example. Chairside Growth is made up, and so are its rivals, called Competitor A to E as in the sample. The opening third of each of its pack files is public in the sample pack; the rest comes with the pack, and the source notes below say which lines come from that part. Both answers come from real runs, copied as they came back.
The question
"Our competitors sell the same services we do. What should our homepage say so a prospect can tell us apart?"
The answer that works depends on what your rivals already say. Positioning is also the first fix on Sam's roadmap in our Agency Score sample, in what is stopping Sam's agency from scaling.
Two answers from the same AI
Same AI, same question, same limit of about 150 words. The first had no files and was told only "I run a six-person dental marketing agency in the UK." The second had Chairside Growth's five pack files and was told to use nothing else.
Without a pack
Don't lead with services. Prospects already assume you do SEO, ads and websites. Lead with what only you can claim.
Your hero line should name who you serve and the result you deliver. For example: "We fill diaries for independent UK practices doing implants and Invisalign." Narrow beats broad.
Then prove it:
- Specific numbers: "Average 31 new implant consultations a month across 14 clients", not "proven results".
- Named case studies: use the practice name, the principal's photo and a quote.
- Your six people: show faces and real dental experience. Being small means a client talks to the person doing the work. Say so.
- Compliance: GDC and ASA advertising rules. Many generalist agencies get these wrong.
- A clear offer: a fixed-price audit or a "no long contracts" promise.
Test it by covering your logo. If a competitor could use the same page, rewrite it.
With the pack
Don't lead with your services. "Local SEO, Google Ads, Landing pages" is what Competitor B and Competitor C say too, so a prospect couldn't tell you apart. Say this instead:
Headline: Fill the implant and Invisalign slots already in your diary.
Under it: We point your Google profile, reviews, local search and ads at the treatment you have private slots free for, and your reception books every enquiry the way it does now.
Proof line: One independent practice booked 23 implant consultations within four months on our Growth plan.
Button: Book a call about your free slots.
The front desk line sets you apart from Competitor A, whose guarantee needs its AI front desk, deposits and reception training. Drop "booked patients over clicks", because it reads as Competitor B's line. Keep the practice unnamed until its owner agrees to be named.
Source POSITIONING.md, "Your homepage, as it would read", "Primary competitive gap", "Stop saying, start saying" and "Open checks before launch"; COMPETITORS.md, "Honest test" and "How you differ". Chairside Growth sample pack. From the part that comes with the pack, not the public opening: that Competitor B and Competitor C list the same three services, and the advice to drop "booked patients over clicks". The homepage lines, the Competitor A contrast and the naming rule are public.
What the plain answer gets right
It's good advice. Don't lead with services, name who you serve, prove it with numbers and names, and test the page by covering the logo.
But it can't take its own test. It doesn't know what any rival's homepage says, so it can't tell which claims are already taken. Its "no long contracts" idea is one Chairside couldn't use: its rival Competitor A lets practices leave every 90 days, while Chairside asks for six months. And the "31 consultations across 14 clients" is a made-up example of the format, not a figure from anywhere, so don't copy it.
What the pack adds
The second answer is the logo test, run against five rivals.
- What is already taken. A list of services says nothing a prospect can't read on two other sites. "Booked patients over clicks" sounds sharp, but Competitor B's homepage already promises it.
- The ground nobody stands on. Competitor A rebuilds reception to deliver its guarantee. Competitor D and Competitor E don't run ads. So local search, the Google profile, reviews and ads on one retainer, with the front desk left alone, is a place none of them stands.
- Proof that is safe to use. The 23 consultations are real inside the sample, but the owner hasn't agreed to be named, so the proof line says "one independent practice".
Where the open ground comes from
The pack's competitor file checks what each rival claims and what it can show, then lists what nobody addresses well. For Chairside it found three gaps: a booking in the practice's own diary traced back to the search or ad behind it, a result with a practice owner's name on it, and everything Google with the front desk left alone.
Only the third goes on the homepage today. The diary report is still in beta and written into no plan, so the pack holds that claim back until it is. The same rule decides what goes in Chairside's offer. It also lists the claims the market is tired of, and who owns each one:
- "Award-winning" or "highest rated". Competitor E and Competitor D own those words, and their proof is design.
- Percentages with no practice behind them. Owners have seen Competitor B's and Competitor C's, and believe a count with a plan and a period.
- Impressions, rankings and cost per click. Those are the figures on the reports buyers stopped trusting.
Source COMPETITORS.md, "Competitors" and "Gaps"; POSITIONING.md, "Primary competitive gap" and "Stop saying, start saying". Chairside Growth sample pack. Public: that the diary report is in beta and on no plan, and Competitor A's 90 day terms. From the part that comes with the pack: the three gaps, the ground nobody stands on (above) and the tired claims.
Positioning that stands out isn't a better sentence about you. It's the sentence your rivals have left you.
The questions the pack asks to get there
The Positioning Pack builds these files from your answers, your client list and its own research on the rivals you name. These are five of the questions it asks:
- What do you sell? Services, packages, price points.
- Who do you lose deals to, or who do clients compare you with? Name two or three, and add their websites if you know them.
- Which of those are live today, which are being built, and which are still ideas?
- What had they tried before you, and why didn't it work for them?
- When a good client talks about the difference you've made, what do they say?
Your answers become the competitor map, the gaps and the homepage lines. Then you can ask the files anything, such as which claim to lead a proposal with.
How we ran it
Both answers came from fresh Claude agents with no other context, on 10 November 2026, one run each. The agent with the pack read the five full files behind the public Chairside Growth sample and nothing else. Nothing in either answer was edited.